HUD Report on H. Sandy Progress – update

As of July 2, I still cannot find any additional information about the National Disaster Resilience Competition.

But I did see this item of interest on the HUD website: HUD RELEASES PROGRESS REPORT ON SANDY REBUILDING STRATEGY; Report Tracks Progress On Recommendations of Sandy Task Force

The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development’s (HUD) Sandy Program Management Office (PMO) today issued its first report tracking progress on the Sandy Rebuilding Strategy. The report is now available online.

Revised Housing Recovery Plan for NJ

If at first you do not succeed, file a formal complaint and try again!

New Jersey Reaches Deal on Hurricane Sandy Aid. From the NYTimes on May 30th:

New Jersey has agreed to spend more federal disaster money to provide housing to people displaced by Hurricane Sandy and to make sure that the hardest-hit parts of the state get a proportional share of the money, according to a settlement reached on Friday.

The state also agreed to reconsider all of the applications for reconstruction aid that were rejected, after a review found that more than three-fourths of them should have been approved. The agreement stemmed from complaints by civil rights groups filed last year with the federal Department of Housing and Urban Development.

“We have one more chance to get this right, and I am hopeful that this agreement will help the state do a better job,” said Frank Argote-Freyre, president of the Latino Action Network, one of the groups that filed the original complaint.

“Ten Indicators of H. Sandy Recovery”

From the site NJ.com: See: 10 indicators of Hurricane Sandy recovery. The lead in to the list of 10 follows:

Nineteen months after Sandy, how far along are New Jersey and its residents in getting back on their feet? It’s clear that substantial progress has been made from the days when boardwalks were heaps of rubble and piles of sand and debris lined the streets.

But how much work remains to be done, and what challenges lie ahead? Here’s a sampling of 10 indicators providing snapshots of where the recovery stands at this point.

Build It Back – just not happening in NY post-Sandy

As was noted in the Lament posting last week, the housing recovery in NY and NJ is going far slower than anyone likes. From the Huff Post, this article titled Doubt Lingers for New Yorkers Devastated by Hurricane Sandy. The article is a bit windy to start with, but here are a few essential quotes:

In 2013 New York City received a total of $3.22 billion in federal grants for Sandy disaster relief and rebuilding. About $650 million of that money was designated for a program called NYC Build it Back, which former Mayor Mike Bloomberg announced in June 2013. The program is intended to help all residents who owned property at the time of the storm. Build it Back prioritizes low- and middle-income New Yorkers — meaning individuals who earn less than $48,100, or a four-person household that pulls in $68,700 annually.

But Build it Back has been a phantom presence, so far, in all damaged Sandy areas. It is drawing the ire of residents and of politicians alike, including New York City Comptroller Scott Stringer, who announced in April that his office is launching an official audit of the city program.

Feds Have a Change in Mind for Sandy Recovery Money for NJ and NY

I just posted an article about what the new mayor of NYC has in mind to expedite the recovery from H. Sandy. It notes that the mayor  was assuming not only the federal dollars pledged to date but was planning to request another $1B to accomplish the expeditious actions he outlined.

Today in the Wall St. Journal, an article suggested that not only will the states of NY and NJ not get more money, they will not get the full amount allocated to date.  I invite corrections if I am wrong. See: More Than $1 Billion in Superstorm Sandy Aid Could Leave Region; New York, New Jersey Lawmakers Call for Disaster Relief to Remain in Area. Here are some excerpts:

More Than $1 Billion in Superstorm Sandy Aid Could Leave Region New York, New Jersey Lawmakers Call for Disaster Relief to Remain in Area By Laura Kusisto and Josh Dawsey Wall Street Journal April 20, 2014

Federal officials are considering spending more than $1 billion of the remaining $3.6 billion of rebuilding aid on disasters other than superstorm Sandy, money that New York and New Jersey are banking on to finish repairs to thousands of homes and complete major infrastructure projects.

The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, which is in charge of distributing the aid, believes that spreading the funds around to disasters other than Sandy is required by federal law, according to people familiar with the matter. New York officials dispute that interpretation.

Note that HUD is responsible for managing the Community Development Block Grant funds, which make up the lion’s share of the recovery money from H. Sandy.

_______________________________________________________________

Thanks to Tom Antush for pointing out this article and link.

H. Sandy Recovery – blame at every level

There is no shortage of people/organizations to blame for the slow and costly process of recovery in NJ and NY. Regarding NJ, recently Governor Christie blamed FEMA. Today, Senator Menendez blames the state government in Trenton. See: Sen. Menendez Blames Trenton for Slow Hurricane Sandy Recovery. Also, under consideration is a proposed Bill of Rights for recovery coming from a State Senator and aimed at the head of the Dept. of Community Affairs in NJ. Here are some excerpts from the news article:

US senators from New Jersey and New York today questioned the head of the Department of Housing and Urban Development about the slow pace of recovery from Hurricane Sandy.

At a hearing held by a subcommittee of the Senate Banking Committee in Washington, DC, HUD secretary Shaun Donovan (below) insisted his agency has changed current rules to speed things up.

This pace of spending is 48 percent faster than after Hurricane Katrina,” Donovan told senators Robert Menendez (D-N.J.) and Charles Schumer (D-N.Y.), “and more than 2½ times faster than after Hurricane Ike.”

Menendez was complimentary of HUD’s role but suggested there has been a lot of bureaucratic footdragging at the state level.

“I thought it was a good idea to give states the flexibility and discretion that seemed reasonable, assuming we would all rise to the occasion,” he said, “and now, frankly, I question the wisdom of that assumption.”

No state officials accepted an invitation to testify but, during the hearing, the Christie administration announced plans to streamline release of funds to distressed homeowners still waiting for help.

___________________________________________________________________

NOTE: I highlighted in red some interesting facts that I have not seen before.  I hope this is a positive indicator of improved federal capabilities and performance during recovery.

Lack of Progress in Rebuilding Post Sandy

Here are three recent articles about how slowly the recovery is proceeding in NYC.  And of course NJ is having its own set of problems rebuilding.  Here are two takes on the NYC situation:

(1) City is slacking on Hurricane Sandy aid for homeowners: report

Of the 19,920 people who applied for the Build It Back program, none have seen construction work start and only 110 had signed a deal on aid as of last month, according to data analyzed by the Alliance for a Just Rebuilding.

(2) Build It Back Has ‘to Do Better’ at Releasing Sandy Funds, Mayor Says

And here is an account of the problems in NJ:

Gov. Christie Blames Slow Sandy Recovery on Federal Governmentg

Hurricane Sandy Recovery Revisited

Here are three new perspectives on the H. Sandy recovery process. The first is from a blog called Politics of the Environment; Discussing Environmental Public Policy and the article is Your Tax Dollars At Work or Not. I believe the author was a member of the H. Sandy Rebuilding Task Force. Here is an excerpt:

I would like to be be discussing the progressive and forward thinking approach to rebuilding that New Jersey has taken in the aftermath of Sandy. But I can’t. I would like to describe the intelligent and measured plan to spend the billions of dollars in federal Sandy aid that has poured into the state. But I can’t. I would like to list the dozens of coordinated programs designed to re-shape the future of New Jersey as a place where vulnerability to future storms and the effects of climate change on a coastal state are being adequately addressed. But I can’t. I would like to say that in response to Sandy’s destruction New Jersey is fundamentally re-assessing how and where we occupy vulnerable areas of the coast. But I can’t. What I can say is that something has gone wrong, very wrong, with the state’s handling of Sandy recovery.

The second is a cool, neutral review of the process from the Congressional Research Service. See Hurricane Sandy Rebuilding Strategy; In Brief. One of the key points made in this report is the need to determine if the recovery task force mechanism is necessary and successful.

The third, available from NJ.com on Feb. 20th, is titled Sandy Aid Went to Projects  Far from the Storm.

Local Officials Want Database of Sandy Recovery Expenditures

Victims want to know when they can expect money and taxpayers want to know where there money is going.  Both are sensible expectations, but not usually easy to answer post disaster.

Local officials in NY are working on legislation to make the expenditures of the billions of federal dollars allocated for H. Sandy reconstruction and recovery more transparent for those affected.  See this article from local paper.

Note that the federal government has a post-Sandy expenditure system in place. It is on the Dept. of HUD website page with the H. Sandy Rebuild Task Force Report. Direct URL is here, though I am not sure how current the data is.